| St. Bonaventure Parish | First Presbyterian Church | St. John Lutheran Church |
 |
 |
 |
| Allegany Baptist Church | 3236 Maple Ave Allegany, NY |
Founded in 1964 |
| Church of God of Prophecy | 71 W Main St Allegany, NY |
Founded ?? |
| First Free Methodist | 2535 Five Mile Rd Allegany, NY |
Founded in August of 1860 |
| First Presbyterian Church | 44 N. Third St Allegany, NY |
Founded ?? |
| Full Gospel Church | 50 N. Third St Allegany, NY |
Founded ?? |
| St. Bonaventure Parish | 93 Main St Allegany, NY |
Founded:1874 Built In 1931* |
| St. John Lutheran Church |
36 N 4th St Allegany, NY (716) 373-0025 |
Established August 4, 1861 |