Please note: This index was made many years ago for the Cattaraugus County Museum at Little Valley, NY and has been digitized by a team of Cattaraugus County researchers. There will be errors, given the difficulty in deciphering some of the handwriting of the original census records. Please check the names carefully, as your family's name may have simply been misspelled or misread.
| Name | Page # |
| Agle, Josiah | 427 |
| Ames, Amenzo L. | 429 |
| Ames, Alphonso | 443 |
| Amidon, Franklin | 432 |
| Anderson, Charles H | 444 |
| Anderson, Emery | 444 |
| Annis, Lyman C. | 432 |
| Ansel, Charles | 449 |
| Antisdel, Pauline | 445 |
| Arnold, Leander | 444 |
| Arnold, Jane | 444 |
| Austin, Perry | 441 |
| Ayers, Alfred | 440 |
| Barrows, Grenville | 447 |
| Beardsley, Wheeler | 445 |
| Beman, John | 447 |
| Benson, John | 433 |
| Berlin, Christian L. | 440 |
| Bidan, John | 435 |
| Bisbee, Ahan | 451 |
| Blendinger, John | 449 |
| Blendinger, Lawrance | 441 |
| Booth, Nancy | 439 |
| Borden, Mary E. | 435 |
| Botsford, Luson | 445 |
| Botsford, Luzon M. | 444 |
| Botsford, Theophilus | 444 |
| Bowen, Hermon D. | 435 |
| Brainard, Loring G. | 449 |
| Brainard, Simeon S. | 449 |
| Brisley, Stephe | 451 |
| Brooks, Duglas M. | 447 |
| Brown, Horace | 429 |
| Brown, Nathan C. | 428 |
| Bryant, Nathaniel | 429 |
| Bryant, Stillman N. | 429 |
| Bucklin, Daniel | 441 |
| Bucklin, Fuller | 441 |
| Bucklin, Helen L. | 441 |
| Bullard, Allen B. | 444 |
| Button, John | 432 |
| Calkins, John (Corcoran) | 436 |
| Carpenter, Josiah | 444 |
| Carrol, Timothy | 431 |
| Chapman, James | 447 |
| Chase, Abner | 442 |
| Chase, Alvan | 429 |
| Chase, Alzina W. | 429 |
| Chase, Henry | 441 |
| Chase, Nancy | 428 |
| Chase, Tracy | 433 |
| Childs, David | 440 |
| Clement, Solomon | 433 |
| Collins, Jerry | 447 |
| Congdon, James G. | 444 |
| Conklin, Benjamin H. | 433 |
| Conners, Daniel | 447 |
| Connor, Thomas | 431 |
| Cool, Abner | 452 |
| Cornell, William C. | 453 |
| Cory, Hiram | 453 |
| Courin, Patrick | 447 |
| Crandal, Edwin O. | 447 |
| Crosby, Nathan | 440 |
| Crosby, Stephen | 431 |
| Cullen, John | 451 |
| Culver, Eliphalet | 433 |
| Cummings, Edwin B. | 443 |
| Cuningham, Daniel | 427 |
| Daily, John | 436 |
| Dalahoy, David | 433 |
| Davenport, Franklin | 447 |
| Davis, Elisher J. | 449 |
| Donaldson, Daniel | 431 |
| Driskel, Michael | 436 |
| Dye, Henry | 439 |
| Eagan, John | 427 |
| Eams, Ezra W. | 445 |
| Ellis, Delos | 457 |
| Ellis, John | 437 |
| Escritt, Thomas | 444 |
| Ethridge, Tracy C. | 431 |
| Fairbrother, Orlando | 449 |
| Fass, Fredrick | 453 |
| Fay, Cynthia | 446 |
| Fields, AsahelW. | 437 |
| Finch, Smith HR | 453 |
| Finnin, Thomas | 444 |
| Fisher, Harvy J. | 449 |
| Fisher, Nancy | 449 |
| Flinn, Michael | 435 |
| Foot, Frank | 440 |
| Foster, Chester | 438 |
| Fuller, Adalade | 447 |
| Fuller, Benjamin | 443 |
| Fuller, Cyrus A. | 441 |
| Fuller, Lucia B. | 441 |
| Gage, John | 427 |
| Gallagher, John | 428 |
| Gano, Jay | 447 |
| Gates, Labon | 440 |
| Gaylord, Henery C. | 441 |
| Gaylord, Lydia C. | 444 |
| Godding, Levi | 443 |
| Godding, William W. | 445 |
| Green, Jefferson A. | 451 |
| Green, Stephen C. | 445 |
| Hale, Walton | 435 |
| Hale, David | 435 |
| Halle, Hiram A | 432 |
| Harmon, Mary C. | 444 |
| Hawks, Betsy | 446 |
| Heart(Hart),Horace | 449 |
| Heller, Augustus | 443 |
| Hermon, Lysander E. | 432 |
| Herrington, Caleb B | 433 |
| Herrington, Daniel | 448 |
| Hickey, Freman | 443 |
| Hickey, John | 443 |
| Higbee, Louise | 445 |
| Hildreth, Daniel H. | 451 |
| Hittsley, George | 447 |
| Holcomb, Oliver | 441 |
| Hollebeck, Derick | 440 |
| Hollenbeck, Kellogg | 434 |
| Houghton, Mary D. | 433 |
| Hover, Augustus | 448 |
| How, Samuel | 437 |
| How, Horrace | 445 |
| Hoyt, Henery | 449 |
| Huckins, Albert | 427 |
| Huntly, Rufus | 432 |
| Ingalls, William | 452 |
| Jackson Amasy | 445 |
| Jackson, Ransom | 453 |
| Johnson, Alfred L. | 433 |
| Johnson, Peter | 432 |
| Kating, John | 447 |
| Keith, Albert | 433 |
| Keith, John H | 448 |
| Kilbourn, George | 429 |
| Kilburn, Alfred | 433 |
| King, Joshua | 443 |
| King, Thomas S. | 435 |
| Kinyon, Asa B. | 454 |
| Knox, Mattie | 443 |
| Lee, Erastus N. | 431 |
| Leech, John | 437 |
| Lemise, Clark | 445 |
| Leslie, John | 431 |
| Lillie, David | 453 |
| Little, Thomas | 437 |
| Loop, Lucy J. | 444 |
| Luce, Franklin | 451 |
| Luce, Lucius T. | 452 |
| Manly, John | 442 |
| Manning, Lyman | 439 |
| Markham, Benjimin | 437 |
| Markham, Isaac P. | 440 |
| Markham, William J | 436 |
| Marsh, Sidney S. | 445 |
| Martindale, Olive | 444 |
| McCarty, Calahan | 436 |
| McCarty, Charles | 448 |
| McFaile, Charles | 441 |
| McGuire, Nancy | 443 |
| McKay, Hiram V. | 439 |
| McMillen, Edwin L. | 427 |
| McVey, John | 453 |
| Meaker, Nelson | 428 |
| Menroe, John | 453 |
| Merow, John | 457 |
| Metsker, Fredrick | 435 |
| Miller, Amelia | 429 |
| Morrill, Isac J. | 427 |
| Morris, Hermy | 442 |
| Morris, James | 434 |
| Mosher, W. Henery | 449 |
| Osgood, Rachel | 427 |
| Osgood, Stephen J. | 433 |
| Parker, Chauncy A. | 445 |
| Parker, Fredrick | 427 |
| Peabody, Luther | 432 |
| Perigo, Edgar D. | 452 |
| Perry, Abner | 431 |
| Petrie, Richard W. | 445 |
| Phiney, Orin | 440 |
| Porter, Elizabeth | 435 |
| Puddy, Charles J. | 429 |
| Puddy, Elisha | 440 |
| Quigly, James | 448 |
| Randall, Ada | 431 |
| Raynolds, Jeptha | 452 |
| Reed, Stephen | 432 |
| Rian, William | 436 |
| Robinson, Seth | 449 |
| Russel, Thomas | 443 |
| Ryan, Mary | 439 |
| Saulsbury, Hiram | 445 |
| Sibly, Ira | 440 |
| Smidt, John C. | 440 |
| Snider, Clarrissa | 440 |
| Southern, Eliza | 445 |
| Sprague, Christopher L. | 441 |
| Sprague, Lewis | 440 |
| Sprague, Luther | 441 |
| Starks, Chester | 429 |
| Starks, John W. | 428 |
| Stevens, Levi | 453 |
| Stratten Lorenso | 428 |
| Stratten, Alenzo | 428 |
| Stratten, Tebulen | 437 |
| Stratton, James | 428 |
| Stratton, Leander | 428 |
| Sullivan, Jerry | 431 |
| Sullivan, Thomas | 452 |
| Sweetland, Asa | 449 |
| Sweetland, Asa, Junior | 449 |
| Sweetland, Emery J. | 450 |
| Sweetland, Lewis | 450 |
| Sykes, Emma J. | 445 |
| Thompson, Jonathan | 427 |
| Thompson, Joseph F. | 446 |
| Thompson, Oscar B | 443 |
| Thompson, Sherman | 442 |
| Town, George | 428 |
| Turness, Asa | 439 |
| Twomay, William | 435 |
| Twomley, Lyman | 447 |
| Uber, Michael | 431 |
| Van Aernam, Lafayette | 439 |
| Velzy, Henry | 433 |
| Velzy, Milton | 432 |
| Wait, John J. | 428 |
| Walker, Richard M. | 454 |
| Watkins, Zephi | 452 |
| Wellington, Horace | 439 |
| Wheat, Elias A | 452 |
| Wheat, Johnithan | 435 |
| Wheaton, Gaius | 429 |
| Wheaton, Norman | 429 |
| Wheeler, Plinny | 437 |
| Wheeler, Rhoda | 428 |
| Whipple, Samuel J,. | 448 |
| Wilcoks, Allina J. | 443 |
| Williamson, Jane | 432 |
| Willis, Chauncey | 432 |
| Willis, Hezekiah | 432 |
| Willoughby, Reuben | 445 |
| Wilson, Seneca R. | 443 |
| Winship, Charles | 439 |
| Winship, Isaac | 431 |
| Winship, Truman | 431 |
| Woodard, William | 449 |
| Woodrough, Morris | 452 |
| Woodworth, Clarinda | 427 |
| Woodworth, George | 427 |
| Woodworth, Leroy | 427 |
| Woodworth, William | 427 |
| Woolman, Lenuel | 427 |
| Wyman, Emory T. | 427 |