Please note: This index was made many years ago for the Cattaraugus County Museum at Little Valley, NY and has been digitized by a team of Cattaraugus County researchers. There will be errors, given the difficulty in deciphering some of the handwriting of the original census records. Please check the names carefully, as your family's name may have simply been misspelled or misread.
The Town of Great Valley can be found on the 2nd (Volume 2) of 3 microfilms of the 1865 NY State Census for Cattaraugus County made by the LDS church
| NAME: | Page # of Microfilm |
| Abbott, Timothy L. | 77 |
| Adams, Augustus | 62 |
| Adams, James | 73 |
| Akers, Edward | 99 |
| Alexander, John | 75 |
| Allard, William | 102 |
| Ames, Henry W. | 86 |
| Ankenbah, Martin | 95 |
| Arnold, John | 91 |
| Bachus, Edward | 93 |
| Bacon, Sylvester | 65 |
| Bailett, F.E. | 71 |
| Bailett, J.H. | 73 |
| Ballard, Msael | 96 |
| Barber, Sanford | 86 |
| Barker, Isabell | 62 |
| Barker, William | 80 |
| Bartlett, William | 102 |
| Barton, Jessa L. | 68 |
| Bates, Andrew P. | 85 |
| Beach, Lucinda | 94 |
| Belknap, Ella | 90 |
| Bennett, Sylvia | 93 |
| Birmingham, Bridgett | 94 |
| Birmingham, Michael | 97 |
| Birmingham, William | 103 |
| Bissell, Thomas | 93 |
| Bixby, Fayette | 65 |
| Blighton, Amy | 65 |
| Blood, Andrew J. | 97 |
| Boardman, Rochester | 86 |
| Bonesteel, Nicholas | 83 |
| Booth, Joseph | 82 |
| Bordine, J.F. | 89 |
| Boss, Viola | 71 |
| Bottom, Jacob | 87 |
| Bottom, William | 93 |
| Bowen, Alfonzo | 78 |
| Bradger, Wm. | 87 |
| Brewer, Dewitt | 79 |
| Brewer, George | 75 |
| Brink, Charles | 97 |
| Brink, George | 63 |
| Brink, William | 97 |
| Brooks, Ellen | 66 |
| Brown, Susan | 73 |
| Bryant, Frances | 74 |
| Bryant, Julia F. | 75 |
| Bryant, Sheldon | 75 |
| Bullard, E.H. | 61 |
| Burke, Thomas | 94 |
| Byme, Joseph | 81 |
| Cahoe, John | 99 |
| Calkins, John C. | 61 |
| Camady, Michael | 67 |
| Carl, John | 98 |
| Carl, Michael | 97 |
| Carrier, Clarry | 63 |
| Carrier, Timothy | 86 |
| Carver, Solander | 86 |
| Carver, Susan | 86 |
| Cary, James | 99 |
| Cassady, Alice | 101 |
| Cavanagh, Dennis | 101 |
| Chamberlain, A.W. | 65 |
| Chamberlain, Chandler | 78 |
| Chamberlain, Charles | 79 |
| Chamberlain, Harrison | 69 |
| Chamberlain, Henry T. | 83 |
| Chamberlain, John | 69 |
| Chamberlain, Perry | 63 |
| Chamberlain, Sarah | 65 |
| Chamberlain, Wm. A. | 63 |
| Chapman, Charles A. | 90 |
| Chase, Alexander | 73 |
| Chase, Harley | 70 |
| Chase, J.E. | 70 |
| Chittenden, Miriam | 61 |
| Clancy, Tho. | 70 |
| Clark, Henry S. | 74 |
| Clark, Hiram | 73 |
| Clemons, John | 77 |
| Cleveland, Aaron | 71 |
| Closky, Bartholomew | 71 |
| Coffee, John | 81 |
| Coffee, Mary | 79 |
| Coleman, Harlen | 81 |
| Collins, Jerry | 91 |
| Collins, Mary | 101 |
| Coltart, John | 84 |
| Congdon, Daniel G. | 61 |
| Conklin, Bridgett | 90 |
| Corbet, James | 98 |
| Costalo, Patrick | 101 |
| Cowell, Louisa | 89 |
| Crary, Eugene | 70 |
| Crary, H.H. | 74 |
| Cretty, Patrick | 98 |
| Crick, Robert | 77 |
| Cross, John | 89 |
| Cross, Silas | 78 |
| Cross, William | 104 |
| Cullinan, Edmond | 66 |
| Cullinson, Mary | 74 |
| Culver, Anthony S. | 69 |
| Cummings, Chester | 82 |
| Danahe, James | 99 |
| Danahue, Mary | 89 |
| Davidson, Thomas | 71 |
| Davis, John F. | 87 |
| Degolier, Alfred S. | 93 |
| Derry, Feinando | 92 |
| Didcock, Henry | 88 |
| Dodge, Calvin | 62 |
| Dodge, Lydia | 71 |
| Dolph, Isaac | 66 |
| Donolon, Margaret | 66 |
| Drake, T.F. | 65 |
| Duffee, John | 74 |
| Dugan, Michael | 98 |
| Dupy, Jonas | 85 |
| Eder, Michael | 93 |
| Elderkin, Sarah | 61 |
| Ellis, Chloe | 65 |
| Evans, Harriet A. | 89 |
| Evans, Smith | 102 |
| Falts, Daniel | 93 |
| Farnum, David | 86 |
| Farrington, Maria | 86 |
| Farty, Sylvester | 74 |
| Fay, Alexander | 67 |
| Fay, Sarah | 62 |
| Fisk, Wm. T. | 90 |
| Fitts, J.G. | 101 |
| Fitzgerald, Robert | 82 |
| Flint, Esther | 62 |
| Flint, Nicholas | 61 |
| Flint, Orville | 63 |
| Flynn, Hugh | 91 |
| Folts, Henry | 88 |
| Folts, Peter | 87 |
| Foster, Chester | 69 |
| Foster, Edward W. | 73 |
| Fowler, Geo. | 86 |
| Francis, D.N. | 63 |
| Frank, Jerry | 90 |
| Frank, Joseph | 87 |
| Fredenburg, Alonzo | 93 |
| Galvin, Michael | 100 |
| Garby, John | 91 |
| Gardner, Horatio | 73 |
| Gardner, Julia A. | 71 |
| Gillis, Malcom | 86 |
| Gorman, John | 83 |
| Granfield, Michael | 101 |
| Granger, Josephine | 80 |
| Granger, Lester | 97 |
| Gray, Amasa L. | 77 |
| Green, Benj. | 85 |
| Green, Diamond | 102 |
| Green, James | 85 |
| Green, John | 88 |
| Green, Joseph | 63 |
| Griffin, Patrick | 95 |
| Hagarty, Michael | 101 |
| Hall, Wm. W. | 67 |
| Hallady, Reuben | 69 |
| Halleck, Peter | 94 |
| Hallsted, DW. | 85 |
| Hanlin, John | 79 |
| Hanson, N.V. | 95 |
| Harrington, Sam’s | 75 |
| Harris, F.J. | 61 |
| Harrison, Wm. H. | 91 |
| Harvey, David | 76 |
| Hatch, Phillip | 87 |
| Haughtaling, Alvah | 77 |
| Haughtaling, Horace | 67 |
| Haughtaling, Levi | 78 |
| Herrick, N.P. | 66 |
| Hewett, Schuyler | 67 |
| Hicks, Abel | 63 |
| Hicks, J.P. | 77 |
| Hiler, Charles | 89 |
| Hillman, B.B. | 66 |
| Hitchcock, Thomas C. | 66 |
| Hogan, John | 62 |
| Hogan, Michael | 98 |
| Horton, Henry | 94 |
| Horton, Mary | 85 |
| Howe, Alice | 79 |
| Howe, Mary | 89 |
| Howe, Maryette | 63 |
| Howe, Nancy | 62 |
| Howland, Phebe A. | 103 |
| Hoyt, Edwin | 87 |
| Hubbard, Margaret | 97 |
| Hubbard, T.B. | 90 |
| Hull, Heman, | 81 |
| Hull, Hiram | 81 |
| Hull, James | 81 |
| Hurd, Benj. | 93 |
| Hurlburt, Caleb | 101 |
| Hyatt, Newel | 103 |
| Jager, John | 102 |
| Jenks, Elijah C. | 89 |
| Jessup, Isa | 89 |
| Johnson, William | 86 |
| Jones, Asa | 85 |
| Jones, Joseph | 100 |
| Jones, Lyman | 71 |
| Kane, Peter | 87 |
| Kating, Sylvester | 99 |
| Kelley, Robert | 65 |
| Kelsey, Erasmus D. | 77 |
| Kelsey, Kathalo | 65 |
| Kenedy, James | 98 |
| Keuhlalexr, Alex. | 90 |
| Kilburn, Edward | 103 |
| Kilburn, George | 93 |
| Kilburn, Samuel | 103 |
| Killinger, John | 91 |
| Kingsley, Nelson A. | 103 |
| Lamb, R.L. | 74 |
| Latin, L.B. | 78 |
| Lawler, Julia | 102 |
| Lawton, Catharine | 63 |
| Lawton, Hannah | 79 |
| Lawton, Peleg. | 79 |
| Lawton, Perry | 79 |
| Lawton, Thomas | 78 |
| Lay, William | 66 |
| Layton, Jeremiah | 92 |
| Lemon, Oscar | 70 |
| Leslie, David | 90 |
| Lindsey, David | 91 |
| Lofener, J.J. | 78 |
| Lynch, John | 95 |
| Malony, James | 96 |
| Mandeville, Thomas | 83 |
| Mann, John | 66 |
| Manson, Benj. | 94 |
| Markham, Betsey | 70 |
| Marsh, Allen, H. | 92 |
| Marsh, Ambrose | 63 |
| Marsh, Otis | 91 |
| Marvin, F.A. | 70 |
| Mathewson, Cordelia J. | 83 |
| Maybee, Abram | 102 |
| Mc Intire, Henry | 65 |
| McAfee, James | 79 |
| McCan, Thomas | 90 |
| McCarty, Daniel | 101 |
| McCarty, Dennis | 81 |
| McCarty, Mary | 99 |
| McClure, Sidney | 70 |
| McCoy, B. | 80 |
| McCoy, John | 77 |
| McCoy, S.W. | 87 |
| McGraw, Michael | 67 |
| McGuire, Edward | 91 |
| McIntosh, Edwin | 73 |
| McKeane, Peter | 102 |
| McKenna, Edward | 101 |
| McNamara, Patrick | 62 |
| McNamara, Thomas | 94 |
| McWithy, Lurancia | 80 |
| Melhuish, John H. | 102 |
| Melony, James | 101 |
| Melvin, Calvin | 74 |
| Merkt, Mary | 91 |
| Merrill, Smith | 63 |
| Messenger, Peter | 91 |
| Moore, Eliza | 72 |
| Moose, James | 95 |
| Morgan, Alatheah | 63 |
| Morgan, Leonard | 97 |
| Morgan, Tureman | 90 |
| Morton, Hugh | 82 |
| Morton, John | 82 |
| Morton, Robert | 76 |
| Morton, William | 82 |
| Mudgett, Abram | 81 |
| Mularky, John | 101 |
| Murphy, James | 74 |
| Murphy, John | 74 |
| Murphy, Michael | 80 |
| Nelson, James | 77 |
| Nelson, Margaret | 62 |
| Newlan, Joseph | 102 |
| Nihill, Michael | 73 |
| Niles, George | 81 |
| Niles, Lovina T. | 65 |
| Niles, Squire | 83 |
| Nobles, Cosdelia | 105 |
| Nobles, Spencer T. | 105 |
| Nooks, James | 94 |
| Norton, Andrews L. | 103 |
| Norton, Ira | 104 |
| O’brien, Luke | 97 |
| O’Connor, Marth | 81 |
| O’Dey, Patrick | 97 |
| O’Heron, John | 82 |
| Ohern, Anora | 74 |
| Orbeson, Alexr. | 85 |
| Palmer, Stephen | 78 |
| Patterson, Robert | 89 |
| Pemberton, Clarissa | 90 |
| Phelps, J.W. | 89 |
| Pierce, Sidney | 85 |
| Plamer, John | 91 |
| Post, Julia A. | 97 |
| Potter, John | 75 |
| Powell, Louisa | 89 |
| Powers, John | 101 |
| Putman, Joseph | 73 |
| Quilter, Bridget | 101 |
| Rablin, Mary A. | 78 |
| Ragan, Dennis | 99 |
| Ralph, Wm. | 85 |
| Rasey, A.W. | 79 |
| Reed, Daniel R. | 69 |
| Richardson, James | 69 |
| Rickards, Nelson | 72 |
| Riley, Thomas | 98 |
| Roan, Patrick | 74 |
| Roat, David | 102 |
| Rogers, Calvin | 78 |
| Rogers, Nedham | 97 |
| Rowland, Amy | 78 |
| Roy, Alexr. | 79 |
| Russel, John P. | 91 |
| Rust, John | 103 |
| Rust, Lucia | 69 |
| Ryan, Anna | 91 |
| Scanlin, John | 95 |
| Scanlin, Patrick | 94 |
| Scoby, William | 86 |
| Searl, Alonzo | 64 |
| Searl, Arza | 65 |
| Sears, Edmond | 77 |
| Senneare, O.B. | 86 |
| Sera, Peter | 65 |
| Shea, Michael | 95 |
| Shehan, Michael | 97 |
| Shehan, Pat | 95 |
| Sheldon, D.L. | 68 |
| Shorter, Heman S. | 102 |
| Shuler, Adam | 98 |
| Shults, John | 66 |
| Shures, William | 83 |
| Sibley, Charles | 92 |
| Sibley, Sheman | 90 |
| Simerson, Elsa A. | 75 |
| Simmons, Ann | 81 |
| Simmons, Anna | 61 |
| Simmons, Bradley | 83 |
| Simmons, David | 84 |
| Slatery, Patrick | 95 |
| Slemons, Thomas | 89 |
| Smith, Abram | 67 |
| Smith, Daniel | 67 |
| Smith, Ezra | 69 |
| Smith, Francis | 102 |
| Smith, George | 102 |
| Smith, George | 76 |
| Smith, Mary A. | 66 |
| Smith, Robert | 94 |
| Smith, Syren | 68 |
| Smith, Wm. N. | 103 |
| Snow, Jane E. | 69 |
| Sower, Otto | 89 |
| Staunton, Achsah | 74 |
| Stevens, Asa | 73 |
| Stevens, Harriet | 77 |
| Stinson, Ann M. | 71 |
| Stone, Lewis | 68 |
| Stone, Mariah | 67 |
| Sullivan, John | 99 |
| Sullivan, John | 99 |
| Sullivan, Lawrence | 101 |
| Tallman, John | 93 |
| Tenney, Marian | 102 |
| Thomas, Isaac | 71 |
| Thop, Smith | 90 |
| Thorp, Morgan | 85 |
| Vannatter, Henry | 62 |
| Vedder, Vena | 96 |
| Volk, Otto | 103 |
| Walrath, Walter | 71 |
| Ward, Arunah | 61 |
| Ward, Loyal | 61 |
| Ward, Pherson | 61 |
| Weaver, Isabel | 93 |
| Weller, Peter | 102 |
| Wells, | 80 |
| West, Daniel P. | 81 |
| Wetherly, Charles | 71 |
| Whalon, James | 67 |
| Whedon, Wareham | 78 |
| Whitehead, Martha | 77 |
| Whitford, Benj. | 94 |
| Whitney, J.M. | 79 |
| Wilcox, Edwin | 64 |
| Wilcox, Seymore | 64 |
| Williams, Burton | 75 |
| Williams, Hiram | 75 |
| Williams, Horace | 75 |
| Williams, Lyman | 75 |
| Williams, Spencer | 75 |
| Willoughby, Evaline | 104 |
| Willoughby, Weston W. | 61 |
| Witherell, GJ. | 89 |
| Wooster, Jeremy | 94 |
| Wright, David A. | 93 |
| Wright, John G. | 63 |
| Wright, Polly | 73 |
| Wright, Wells | 103 |
| Young, Frank | 103 |
| Young, Frederick | 98 |