Please note: This index was made many years ago for the Cattaraugus County Museum at Little Valley, NY and has been digitized by a team of Cattaraugus County researchers. There will be errors, given the difficulty in deciphering some of the handwriting of the original census records. Please check the names carefully, as your family's name may have simply been misspelled or misread.
The Town of CARROLLTON can be found on the 1st (Volume 1) of 3 microfilms of the 1865 NY State Census for Cattaraugus County made by the LDS church
| NAME: | Page # of Microfilm |
| Adams, Isral | 183 |
| Agan, John | 182 |
| Agan, Patrick | 199 |
| Allen, Charles B | 202 |
| Alma, James | 182 |
| Badman, John | 189 |
| Bailette, Felix | 198 |
| Bailey, Levi D | 181 |
| Baker, George W | 198 |
| Bartlett, Horace | 182 |
| Bartlett, Wilder | 198 |
| Barton, Smith | 187 |
| Bassett, John | 191 |
| Bates, Charles C | 187 |
| Bates, Weston | 187 |
| Battie, Michael | 209 |
| Beardsly, Hiram | 185 |
| Beardsly, William | 184 |
| Bell, Edwin M | 181 |
| Beers, John B | 185 |
| Belden, Marcy | 189 |
| Bolan, Michael | 202 |
| Boonsick, Casper | 186 |
| Bosworth, Alonzo | 189 |
| Bosworth, | 189 |
| Braely, John | 206 |
| Brooks, William | 187 |
| Brown Spaulding R | 181 |
| Brown, Walter G | 203 |
| Bumpus, Byron | 194 |
| Burlew, William E | 186 |
| Burns, James | 182 |
| Burns, John | 182 |
| Cables, William | 198 |
| Caffrey, John | ??? |
| Cagswell, Mason W | 193 |
| Cain, Patrick | ??? |
| Call, Larin | 193 |
| Calvin, Mary | ??? |
| Canty, Timothy | 200 |
| Carkins, Gaorge | 185 |
| Carlin, Lorina | 190 |
| Carroll, James | ??? |
| Carroll, Thomas | 200 |
| Castello, John | 199 |
| Clark, William J | 186 |
| Cary, Andrew | 195 |
| Cary, John | 201 |
| Cary, Patrick | 195 |
| Clark, Barton | ??? |
| Conklin, James | 191 |
| Conklin, Thomas | 197 |
| Connely,Maichal | ??? |
| Conners, Martin | 193 |
| Connor, John | ??? |
| Cowen, Daniel | 186 |
| Cowen, Wm C | 186 |
| Crane, John | ??? |
| Cuddington, Milton | ??? |
| Cuminghen, Edward | 182 |
| Dalton, John | ??? |
| Damon, Alanzo | ??? |
| Dannel, Michael | ??? |
| Daugherty, William | ??? |
| DuBois, Reuben | ??? |
| Duncan, James | ??? |
| Edson, Nathaniel | ??? |
| Fall, Robert | ??? |
| Faly, James | ??? |
| Fanny, Ford | ??? |
| Fe, Thomas | ??? |
| Fee, Richard | ??? |
| Fisk, Catherine | ??? |
| Fisk, Cora | ??? |
| FitzPatrick, Mary | ??? |
| Flynn, Hugh | ??? |
| Frank, Daniel | ??? |
| French, Cynthia B | ??? |
| Fuller, Ronamzo | ??? |
| Geur, John S | ??? |
| Gooden, Albert | ??? |
| Grimes, William | ??? |
| Grogan, George | ??? |
| Grous, Edward | ??? |
| Hacket, John | ??? |
| Hafleck, Adam | ??? |
| Hagan, Michael | 198 |
| Hagan, Michael | 210 |
| Halland, Andrew | 200 |
| Hamilton, John | ??? |
| Hammond, Cyrus | ??? |
| Harger, Henderson | ??? |
| Harris, Marshall D | ??? |
| Hattone, Antone | ??? |
| Hazzard, Ellis | ??? |
| Hazzard, John | ??? |
| Hickey, Joseph | 202 |
| Hill, Albert | ??? |
| Hodge, William | ??? |
| Hooker, Eli | ??? |
| Houg, Robert | 202 |
| Howard, John | 207 |
| Huff, Oerin | ??? |
| Hull, Hansy | ??? |
| Hunt, James | ??? |
| Huntington, Elizabeth | 197 |
| Hutchinson, Daniel A | ??? |
| Irvine, Benjamin F | 201 |
| Jacobs, Shermen | 185 |
| Johnson, Luther | 191 |
| Katon, Barry | 201 |
| Kellogg, Aaron | 181 |
| Kellogg, Charles | 187 |
| Kellogg, G M | 206 |
| Kellogg, Milton | 186 |
| Kellogg, N S | 181 |
| Kellogg, S M | 185 |
| KillPatrick, James | 187 |
| King, Lawrence | 206 |
| Kough, James | 201 |
| Kough, Patrick | 194 |
| Lawton, Phebe | 193 |
| Lawson, Thadeus | 199 |
| Layman, John H | 203 |
| Leonard, Calvin | 191 |
| Leonard, Joseph | 192 |
| Leonard, Levi | 198 |
| Loftes, John | 209 |
| Loop, Annite | 203 |
| Louana, Hannora | 190 |
| Louana, Patrick | 197 |
| Lovell, James | 195 |
| Lovell, John | 193 |
| Lovell, Rebecca | 190 |
| Mack, Anna | 201 |
| Madison, Henry | 186 |
| Mahoney, Patrick | 207 |
| Mantz, George F | 203 |
| Martiny, John | 206 |
| McCarty, Martin | 201 |
| McCarty, Jerry | 191 |
| McClure, Henry H | 202 |
| McGraw, Thomas | 196 |
| McGuire, James | 202 |
| McKenzie, John | 203 |
| McKinny, John | 191 |
| McKune, Pat | 206 |
| McMahon, James | 206 |
| McNamara, John | 194 |
| McNearny, John | 209 |
| McNearny, Joseph | 206 |
| McNearny, Owen | 202 |
| McNearny, Thomas | 199 |
| Merriman, Mary | 204 |
| Milan, Richard | 209 |
| Morrison, Alfred | 202 |
| Morse, Charles | 190 |
| Morse, Timothy | 197 |
| Mulhern, John | 181 |
| Mullalay, William | 206 |
| Muller, Henry | 183 |
| Mulroney, James | 205 |
| Mulroney, John | 199 |
| Murphy, Richard | 201 |
| Murray, James | 205 |
| Nichols, James | 206 |
| Oconnel, Dennis | 182 |
| Ogden, Helon | 202 |
| O’Luaghline, John | 201 |
| O’Laughline, Peter | 201 |
| O’Neil, James | 199 |
| O’Neil, Michael | 194 |
| Orbison, Alexander | 198 |
| Parker, Nelson | 202 |
| Paton, Robert | 195 |
| Pelhan, Joseph | 182 |
| Perry, Benjamin | 197 |
| Pershon, John | 195 |
| Phillips, David | 181 |
| Piersons, Frederick | 182 |
| Pinkerton, Samuel | 190 |
| Pinkerton, Ziba | 203 |
| Quillan, John | 197 |
| Quinlin, John | 205 |
| Quinn, Peter | 194 |
| Rady, John | 208 |
| Renner, Henry | 181 |
| Renner, Phillip | 181 |
| Rice, Ebenezer | 193 |
| Rice, Irn | 185 |
| Rine, John | 207 |
| Roach, Michael | 182 |
| Roachford, James | 120 |
| Roachford, John | 187 |
| Robinson, Joseph | 183 |
| Robinson, Richard | 191 |
| Rockford, James | 201 |
| Rockwell, John | 202 |
| Rodgers, Hiram | 197 |
| Rohan, Malchi | 199 |
| Rohan, Michael | 193 |
| Rohan, Patrick | 205 |
| Rohan, William | 199 |
| Rolan, Hiram | 209 |
| Ross, James | 202 |
| Rouff, John | 204 |
| Rush, Edward | 182 |
| Ryan, Patrick | 207 |
| Schmale, John | 183 |
| Scott, Bradner | 190 |
| Sheffner, Elizabeth | 181 |
| Sheffner, Sebatian | 181 |
| Shepherd, Ambrose | 197 |
| Sherelier, Elias | 202 |
| Sherman, Palmer H | 181 |
| Sherman, Washing A | 183 |
| Shirley, Samuel | 191 |
| Shy, Patrick | 202 |
| Smith, Daniel | 183 |
| Snoaks, Abraham | 183 |
| Spafford, Orange K | 189 |
| Spellacy, John | 210 |
| Spencer, John | 185 |
| Splann, John | 182 |
| Stapleton, Mike | 199 |
| Stapleton, Pat | 195 |
| Stone, Jay | 181 |
| Sullivan, John | 182 |
| Sweet, James | 189 |
| Taggert, Patrick | 193 |
| Thatcher, William | 189 |
| Touhey, Bridget | 199 |
| Touhey, Timothy | 206 |
| Townsend, James | 210 |
| Valentine, Herman B | 206 |
| Vandine, John | 206 |
| Vibbard, Shep L | 206 |
| Vosburgh, Emery P | 189 |
| Wade, Henry | 192 |
| Wade, Joel | 189 |
| Walters, Daniel | 187 |
| Walters, Daniel | 193 |
| Walton, John | 181 |
| Wample, Marcus | 209 |
| Warner, Harriet | 181 |
| Wentworth, | 186 |
| Wheeler, Michael | 207 |
| Whipple, George | 194 |
| Whiting, Oliver | 190 |
| Whitteker, Deloss | 185 |
| Whitteker, William | 198 |
| Williams, Hannah B | 197 |
| Willis, M A | 186 |
| Winslow, George | 183 |
| Winslow, Jane | 183 |
| Wixon, Barnabus | 190 |
| Wixon, Rueben | 182 |
| Wolcott, Otis C | 181 |
| Woodard, Asa | 144 |
| Woodruff, William | 202 |
| Writht, Walter J | 199 |
| Wynn, James | 202 |
| Yeomans, Mattison | 206 |
| Zanys, Isaac | 203 |
| Zeluff, George | 190 |
| Zeluff, James | 181 |
| Zeluff, Marvelous | 204 |